Are you a "Brain in a Vat?"

5/15/2007
k

the "brain-in-a-vat hypothesis" has been used by
contemporary philosophers such as Jonathon Dancy to
argue for  the notion that only one thing that can be
known and verified -

and that one thing is the existence of the self

the brain-in-a-vat hypothesis goes like this -

there is no way to disprove the possibility that you are
a disembodied brain, suspended in a solution, in a vat,
and wired to a computer -

a computer that is feeding you a virtual reality experience

and since you can not rule out the possibility that you are
a brain in a vat, you must be skeptical of all that you believe
to be true -

the ONLY thing you can know for sure is that you exist,
as a consciousness, a Self

Tags: questions
Posted in Philosophy

Comments

Re: "these seemingly benign questions might be a test - from the programmer of the supercomputer" A question that comes to mind reading this is: So? What is my reward if I answer the way that satisfies the programmer?
Posted by anonymous on 8/10/2008 11:07:19 PM
but... you ARE a brain in a vat... your skull. And you ARE experiencing a 'virtual reality', filtered by your senses, which are sampling only a small section of the physical world.
Posted by anonymous on 11/16/2008 4:31:14 PM

Post a Comment

Name:

Email:  

Comment:  

Submit

Menu
Sponsors