Are you a "Brain in a Vat?"

5/15/2007

k


The "brain-in-a-vat hypothesis" has been used by
contemporary philosophers such as Jonathon Dancy
to argue for the notion that only one thing that can
be known and verified.

That one thing is the existence of the self.



The brain-in-a-vat hypothesis goes like this -

there is no way to disprove the possibility that
you are a disembodied brain, suspended in a
solution, in a vat, and wired to a computer
that is feeding you a virtual reality experience.

Further, since you can not rule out the possibility
that you are a brain in a vat, you must be skeptical
of all that you believe to be true -

The ONLY thing you can know for sure is that
you exist, as a consciousness, a Self.



Tags: questions
Posted in Philosophy

Comments

Re: "these seemingly benign questions might be a test - from the programmer of the supercomputer" A question that comes to mind reading this is: So? What is my reward if I answer the way that satisfies the programmer?
Posted by anonymous on 8/10/2008 11:07:19 PM
but... you ARE a brain in a vat... your skull. And you ARE experiencing a 'virtual reality', filtered by your senses, which are sampling only a small section of the physical world.
Posted by anonymous on 11/16/2008 4:31:14 PM
Ha, we dont even exist, its a long story, perhaps you could put it up on your site, it gos by the "if a tree falls in a forest" thiory, "if thers nothing to exspearence anything,dose anything exist?" its an intresting quistion, if you can poke good holes in this feal free, but it made me think.
Posted by hugh on 12/19/2009 3:48:50 PM
Isn't this just a modern day spin to Descartes'thesis?
Posted by a on 1/2/2010 9:58:54 PM

Post a Comment

Name:

Email:  

Comment:  

Submit

Menu
Sponsors